SEO · 8 min read

Should You Hire an SEO Company or Do It Yourself?

· by Steve Fleurant

What brought you here today?

A business owner works on a laptop at his kitchen table

Should you hire an SEO company or do it yourself? It is a fair question for any contractor who wants more calls from Google and is not sure the monthly fee is worth it. The honest answer is that many small local businesses can do a good part of the work themselves, and Google says so. What decides it is not skill. It is how many hours you can protect every week, how crowded your market is, and how fast you need results.

Hire SEO Help or Do It Yourself: The Short Answer

Do it yourself if you run a small business in a market that is not very competitive, you can set aside regular time every week, and you are willing to learn. Google's own guide to hiring an SEO says that if you run a small local business, you can probably do much of the work yourself. Hire help when your week is already full, when competitors in your area are clearly investing, or when you want to grow into new towns or services quickly. For most contractors the practical answer is a split: handle your Google Business Profile and reviews yourself, and pay for the website, content and technical work that takes the most time to do well.

What the Work Actually Is

Before deciding who does it, be clear about what "SEO" means for a local contractor. It is a set of jobs, most of them ongoing:

  • Google Business Profile: correct categories, service area, services, photos, and replies to reviews.
  • Reviews: asking every customer, every time, in a way that follows Google's rules.
  • Service pages: one clear page per main service, written the way homeowners search, with your service area on it.
  • Technical health: a site that loads fast on a phone, works properly, and can be read by Google.
  • Content: answers to the questions customers ask before they call.
  • Local mentions and links: suppliers, associations, local organizations and directories that mention your business.
  • Tracking: knowing which calls and forms came from search, so you can tell whether any of it is working.

Google explains how the map results are ranked in its help page on local ranking: relevance, distance and prominence, where prominence includes how many websites link to your business and how many reviews you have. The same page says there is no way to request or pay for a better local ranking. Every item on the list above feeds one of those three factors, whoever does the work.

What You Can Do Yourself, Starting This Month

These are the jobs with the best return on an owner's time, because they need knowledge of your own business more than technical skill:

  1. Finish your Google Business Profile. Our Google Business Profile checklist walks through every field.
  2. Set up a review habit. Ask every customer the same way after every job. Google's review policy prohibits incentives, asking only happy customers, and asking for specific content, so keep it simple and ask everyone.
  3. Reply to reviews, including the bad ones. Our guide on responding to negative Google reviews has examples.
  4. Check your service pages. Does each main service have its own page that says what you do, where, and how to reach you? If not, write them. You know the work better than any writer.
  5. Connect Google Search Console. It is free and shows which searches you appear for and which pages get clicks.

Google recommends its SEO Starter Guide as the place to begin, and learning the basics pays off either way: it is also how you spot an agency recommending something Google discourages.

When Hiring Makes Sense

Hiring help is usually the better choice when one or more of these is true:

  • The hours are not there. If marketing keeps sliding to "next week", that is the answer. SEO done in bursts and then dropped for months rarely builds anything.
  • Your market is crowded. Search your main service and town. If the top results have detailed service pages, many recent reviews and fast websites, catching up takes more work than a few evenings a month.
  • You want to grow into new areas or services on a deadline, which means building many pages and fixing technical problems at once.
  • The technical side is broken: a slow site, pages Google is not indexing, tracking that does not work. These are the jobs where inexperience costs the most.

If you have tried an employee for this before, our comparison of an in-house marketing hire versus an SEO agency covers that third option.

What Hiring Costs, and How to Compare It With Your Time

In Ahrefs' survey of 439 SEO providers, the most common monthly retainer was $501 to $1,000, and the average hourly rate was $111. Prices for contractors vary widely with the size of the market and the amount of work included. Our article on contractor SEO pricing breaks down what different budgets typically buy.

To compare that with doing it yourself, run your own numbers:

  1. Track how many hours you actually spend on marketing for one month.
  2. Put a value on those hours: what you could earn estimating, selling or running jobs in the same time.
  3. Compare that with a retainer for the same work, and remember that a hired team should also bring experience you would otherwise build through trial and error.

Whichever way you go, results take time. Our article on how long SEO takes for contractors covers what to expect and when.

If You Hire, How to Hire Safely

Google's hiring guide lists questions worth asking any SEO provider: examples of previous work, whether they follow Google Search Essentials, what results they expect and in what timeframe, how they measure success, and their experience in your industry and your area. It also lists warning signs:

  • Nobody can guarantee a number one ranking on Google.
  • Be careful with a company that is secretive or will not explain what it plans to do.
  • Avoid link schemes and offers to submit your site to thousands of search engines.
  • Be wary of firms that email you out of the blue.

Two more rules protect you whatever you hire: keep ownership of your website, domain, Google Business Profile and analytics accounts in your own name, and agree up front how results will be reported, in calls and booked jobs rather than traffic alone. Our checklist for auditing a contractor SEO company goes through this before you sign, and our guide to switching SEO agencies covers the handoff if you change later.

The Split That Works for Most Contractors

You do not have to choose all or nothing. A common, sensible split:

  • Keep in-house: review requests, review replies, Google Business Profile photos and updates, and answering calls and forms fast. These depend on you and your team anyway.
  • Hire out: website structure and speed, technical fixes, service and area pages at scale, content, and tracking setup.

Revisit the decision every few months. What made sense when the business was smaller often stops making sense once your time is worth more on the job or in sales.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can a contractor do SEO with no experience?

Yes, for the basics. Google says a small local business can probably do much of the work itself. A complete Google Business Profile, a steady review habit and clear service pages are within reach of any owner. Technical fixes, content at scale and link building are harder to do well without experience.

How much does it cost to hire an SEO company?

In Ahrefs' survey of 439 SEO providers, the most common monthly retainer was $501 to $1,000 and the average hourly rate was $111. What you pay depends on your market and how much work is included, so ask any provider for a written list of what they will do each month.

When should a contractor hire an SEO company instead of doing it themselves?

When you cannot protect regular time every week, when competitors in your area are clearly ahead, when you want to grow into new towns or services quickly, or when your website has technical problems you cannot fix yourself.

Can an SEO company guarantee first place on Google?

No. Google says no one can guarantee a number one ranking, and that you should find someone else if a company promises it. Google also says there is no way to pay for a better local ranking in the map results.

Can I switch from doing it myself to hiring help later?

Yes. Pages, reviews and profile work you do yourself keep their value when someone else takes over. Keep every account in your own name so the handoff is simple.

Want a Second Opinion?

Everything above is something you can decide and act on yourself. If you would rather have someone look at your website and Google profile with you and say plainly which parts are worth doing yourself, Leads Akolytos offers a free 30-minute strategy call. We work only with home service contractors, with no setup fees and no long-term contracts. You can book a time here.

If you'd like one practical idea like this in your inbox each month, get The Leads Akolytos Monthly: one email a month, unsubscribe any time.

Want this handled for you?

We do this work for home service contractors every day, month-to-month, with no contracts. Book a free 30-minute call and we'll show you where you stand on Google.

Book my free call

Keep reading

Free marketing plan

Get a plan for your own business.

Tell us your trade and service area. We'll check how you show up on Google and send back what to fix first.

  • Where you rank today for the jobs you want
  • What your competitors are doing that you aren't
  • Which plan fits, and what it would cost

Rather call? 571-449-7442

Required field

Fill in the fields marked * and tick the box to send.

Steve Fleurant

Steve reads every request and replies within 1 business day. No contracts, no spam.

Was this page useful?