Web Design · 8 min read

What to Ask a Website Copywriter Before You Hire Them: 7 Questions Most Contractors Skip

· by Steve Fleurant

What brought you here today?

What to Ask a Website Copywriter Before You Hire Them: 7 Questions Most Contractors Skip

What to Ask a Website Copywriter Before Hiring: The Short Answer

Before you hire a website copywriter, ask about their process for learning your business, how they handle your specific trade's technical details, whether the copy is written to generate phone calls and form fills (not just "sound good"), how AI tools factor into their writing, what happens if the first draft misses the mark, how copy gets tested against results, and what you actually own when the project ends.

A copywriter who can answer all seven clearly, with specifics instead of generalities, is worth paying for. One who gets vague or defensive on any of them is a warning sign -- not necessarily disqualifying, but worth pressing on before you sign anything.

Why Vetting Matters More for a Contractor Website Than a Typical Small Business

Most "how to hire a copywriter" advice online is written for ecommerce brands, SaaS startups, or personal-brand consultants. None of that advice accounts for what actually makes a home service website convert: trust signals a homeowner can verify in thirty seconds, service-area and licensing language that has to be accurate, and copy built around getting someone to pick up the phone or fill out a form -- not to read a brand story.

A copywriter who has only ever written for ecommerce product pages will default to that playbook on your site, and it will show. That's the gap this list is built to close -- these are the questions to ask before you hire a website copywriter who has never worked with a trade business before. These are the questions that actually separate a copywriter who understands lead generation for trades from one who writes competent but generic marketing copy.

1. How Will You Learn My Business Before You Start Writing?

A good answer involves a real intake process: a call or questionnaire covering your service area, your actual pricing approach, what makes a lead "qualified" for you, and what your best customers say about why they hired you. A bad answer is "just send me your old website copy and a few bullet points." Copy written without that groundwork reads like it could belong to any contractor in any city, because it could.

2. Have You Written for My Trade Specifically, or Trades in General?

This matters less than it sounds like it should. A copywriter who has written for ten different trades but asks sharp questions about yours is often a better choice than one who has only ever written HVAC copy but doesn't ask any questions at all. Ask to see 2-3 live examples of work for businesses in a similar category (service-area trades, ideally, even if not your exact trade), and read the copy on those actual sites -- not just the writing samples they send you, which can be touched up versions of what actually shipped.

3. Is This Copy Being Written to Convert, or Just to Read Well?

Ask directly: "What is this page supposed to make someone do, and how did you write toward that?" A copywriter focused on conversion will talk about call-to-action placement, how they handle the "why call now instead of later" moment, and how the copy supports whatever your actual sales process is. A copywriter focused purely on craft will talk about tone, voice, and readability -- all genuinely valuable, but secondary to whether the page generates calls. You want someone who can do both, but if forced to choose, conversion-mindedness is the one that affects your revenue.

4. How Much of This Will Be AI-Generated, and How Will You Disclose It?

This is not a trick question, and a good copywriter won't treat it like one. Plenty of skilled writers use AI tools to draft outlines or speed up research -- that's different from shipping unedited AI output as finished copy. Google has been direct about this distinction: its own guidance states that the method of content production (AI-assisted or not) matters less than whether the content is genuinely helpful and demonstrates real expertise, and that content produced primarily to manipulate rankings rather than help people violates its spam policies regardless of how it was written.

The practical version for you: ask what specifically a human is doing in the process, and ask to see a sample that wasn't touched up for the pitch.

5. What Happens If the First Draft Isn't Right?

Get this in writing before you pay anything. How many revision rounds are included, what counts as a "revision" versus a new request, and what the turnaround time looks like. Contractors are busy -- if the agreement gives you one shot to catch everything in a single read-through, you will end up either rushing the review or living with copy that's close but not quite right.

6. How Do We Know If the Copy Is Actually Working?

A copywriter who only talks about delivery and never about results is handing you a finished product and walking away. Ask what they'd expect you to track after the new copy goes live -- form submissions, call volume, time on page, bounce rate on the pages they rewrote -- and whether they're willing to look at that data with you after 60-90 days and suggest a revision if something isn't converting. You're not asking for a guarantee of results (no honest copywriter gives one), you're asking whether they think in terms of outcomes at all.

7. What Do I Own When This Is Over?

Confirm in writing that you own the final copy outright once it's paid for, that there's no ongoing licensing fee, and that you can take it to a different agency or an in-house writer later without restriction. This is a standard term with reputable copywriters, but it's worth confirming before you sign rather than discovering a restriction later.

A Note on Plain Language

One underrated test when you hire a website copywriter: read a writing sample out loud. If it sounds like something you'd actually say to a customer on the phone, that's a good sign. If it sounds like a brochure, that's worth asking about.

Plain, direct language consistently performs better with real users than dense or "professional-sounding" copy -- research from the Nielsen Norman Group has found that even subject-matter experts prefer plain language over jargon-heavy writing, because it's faster to read and easier to trust. For a contractor site, where the reader is often deciding whether to trust you with their home, that matters as much as any keyword.

Should You Write It Yourself Instead?

If none of this sounds worth the vetting process you'd need to hire a website copywriter well, it's a fair question to ask whether you should just write the copy yourself instead of taking the time to hire a website copywriter. We've covered that tradeoff in detail separately -- the short version is that DIY copy is realistic if you have real spare time and are comfortable editing ruthlessly, but most owners underestimate how long it takes to write copy that's both accurate and persuasive while also running their business.

If you'd rather see current pricing before deciding either way, here's what website copywriting typically costs for a contractor business.

Frequently Asked Questions

How much should I expect to pay a website copywriter?

Pricing varies by project scope and page count more than by writer "tier." See our full breakdown of website copywriting costs for contractors for current ranges.

Should the copywriter also handle SEO, or is that a separate service?

Good conversion copy and good SEO copy overlap but aren't identical. Ask directly whether keyword research and on-page optimization are included or billed separately -- it's a very common point of confusion that causes scope disputes later.

Can I just give a copywriter my competitor's website as an example of what I want?

You can share it as a style reference, but be clear you want original copy, not a close paraphrase. A copywriter should be able to capture a tone you like without lifting structure or claims from another business's site.

How long does a typical website copywriting project take?

For a standard contractor site (home page plus a handful of service pages), 2-4 weeks from kickoff to final draft is a realistic range once you account for one or two revision rounds. Larger, multi-location sites take longer.

What's a red flag that tells you not to hire a website copywriter you're talking to?

The biggest one: they can't explain how their copy is supposed to make someone pick up the phone. If every answer is about "voice" and "storytelling" with nothing about the call-to-action or the reader's actual decision, that's a sign they're used to a different kind of client.

Ready to Get This Right the First Time?

If you'd rather skip the vetting process entirely, hire a website copywriter who already gets contractor sites: a team that writes contractor websites specifically -- with your trade, your service area, and your phone number in mind from the first draft -- see how our website copywriting service works, or schedule a free strategy call and we'll walk through what your project would actually look like.

If you'd like one practical idea like this in your inbox each month, get The Leads Akolytos Monthly: one email a month, unsubscribe any time.

Want this handled for you?

We do this work for home service contractors every day, month-to-month, with no contracts. Book a free 30-minute call and we'll show you where you stand on Google.

Book my free call

Keep reading

Free marketing plan

Get a plan for your own business.

Tell us your trade and service area. We'll check how you show up on Google and send back what to fix first.

  • Where you rank today for the jobs you want
  • What your competitors are doing that you aren't
  • Which plan fits, and what it would cost

Rather call? 571-449-7442

Required field

Fill in the fields marked * and tick the box to send.

Steve Fleurant

Steve reads every request and replies within 1 business day. No contracts, no spam.

Was this page useful?